Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Robert Gardiner Hill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Robert Gardiner Hill. Show all posts

The Asylum and the Duelling Doctor



The need for a lunatic asylum in Lincoln had been discussed since the opening of the County Hospital, one of the main promoters of this was Dr Willis of Greatford, the man who treated George III for his madness.  Money for the Asylum was raised through public subscription, some subscribers gave as much as £100 (Worth £9,728.58 today).

 The Lincoln Lunatic Asylum is a Greek revival building designed by Richard Ingleman (1777-1838). Building commenced in 1819 and the Asylum opened for patients on 6th April 1820. It was Britain's first purpose-built Lunatic Asylum and became the first asylum in the country to achieve total abolition of mechanical restraint in 1837.

The buildings stand on grounds of 8 acres, west of Lincoln Castle, which was deliberately planted with trees to shield the patients from "poisonous miasmas" which came from the industrialised parts of Lincoln. 

The Asylum, led by Dr Edward Parker Charlesworth (see below) pioneered new ways of treating mental illness, without the use of restraint and barbaric methods to control patients.
One of the early Medical Superindents was Robert Gardiner Hill, who was a leading doctor in the field of mental illness.

Following the opening of the County Lunatic Asylum at Bracebridge Heath in 1852, there was an increasing emphasis on fee-paying patients. The Asylum was re-named as The Lawn Hospital for the Insane in 1885. 

New kitchens, waiting rooms and offices were built in 1893, designed by W Scorer of Lincoln.
Nurses Hostel was built in 1938 and is now the Charlotte House Hotel

The Hospital was taken over by the National Health Service in 1948 and was finally closed in 1985. The City of Lincoln Council purchased the Lawn in 1986 for £425,000, following extensive refurbishment the complex opened in 1990 as catering and events venue. 

 R W Stokes Ltd purchased the buildings only for £1,000,000 in 2015 for their headquarters and barista training.  


Edward Parker Charlesworth

Edward Parker Charlesworth was born in 1783 in the village of Ossington, Nottinghamshire, the son of John Charlesworth, the local rector. After undergoing initial training at Horncastle under Dr E. Harrison, he studied at Edinburgh University where he graduated as a doctor of medicine in 1807.

In 1805 he married Susannah Rockcliffe, daughter of Dr Rockcliffe of Horncastle.

Dr Charlesworth acquired a large practice in Lincoln and in 1808 he was appointed physician to Lincoln County Hospital, which was then on Michaelgate.

​The Lincoln Lunatic Asylum – a private hospital for the mentally ill –  Dr Charlesworth was appointed as visiting physician.

​His methods were revolutionary – and unpopular – in his work to change the restraint methods employed by medical staff in the majority of mental hospitals. His efforts were soon recognised and an order banning hospital attendants from using restraint or violence was made.

In 1824 he became involved in an argument with Charles Sibthorp of Canwick Hall. Angry words were exchanged at a turnpike meeting which culminated in a duel being fought between the two men. The duel took place on 9th August 1824 in a secluded place between the Carholme and the Burton Plantation. Although shots were fired both men missed and honour was satisfied.

Dr Charlesworth died of paralysis on 21st February 1853 and was buried in St Margaret’s Churchyard, Lincoln.

A statue by Thomas Milnes (1813-1888) was erected in his honour in the grounds of The Lawn and unveiled on 12th July 1854


Robert Gardiner Hill

Robert Gardiner Hill was born in Louth, Lincolnshire in 1811 and was educated at Guy’s and St.Thomas’ Hospitals and qualified as a M.R.C.S. (Member of the Royal College of Surgeons) and a L.S.A. (Licentiate of the Society of Apothecaries) in 1834. In the same year he was appointed house surgeon to the General Dispensary at Lincoln, in 1835 he was elected Medical Superintendant at the Lincoln Lunatic Asylum.

"After he left Lincoln Asylum in 1841 Robert Gardiner Hill went into general practice in Lincoln with another doctor - Harvey - but after a few years started a private mental hospital in Lincoln (note: Eastgate House). ​

"Apparently he was extremely popular in the town for his good work and in 1851 they made him mayor ..... Robert Gardiner Hill then took a private home at Brentford but after two or three years bought Shillingthorpe Hall near Lincoln to do the same type of work on his own.

"He then went back to London and took over Earls Court House where he prospered and died." (Typed note in Dr Harold Gardiner-Hill's Family Book)

He married Charlotte Brown in Lincoln in 1841. He was Mayor of Lincoln in 1853.
His ‘non-restraint’ method, which was ‘a procedure with momentous results to the insane’, led to the widespread practice of this principle in England.
He died of a stroke at his home, Earls Court House, Old Brompton, London, in 1878.

Sources: Obituary: British Medical Journal




The Lost Houses of Lincoln - Eastgate House



Eastgate House was built about 1750 for Sir Cecil Wray, the man who had the Roman east gate demolished in 1763 because it was partly in his garden!

Arthur Trollope, stamp distributor, a member of the Lincolnshire Trollope family lived here from about 1840 for 30 years 

Robert Gardiner Hill, of the Lincoln Lunatic Asylum, used part of the house for private mental health treatment.


Lincolnshire Chronicle 30th December 1853

Septimus Lowe, the Lincoln Coroner, bought the house in about 1880. Michael Drury designed alterations and additions to the house. Tenders ranged in price from £2,134 to £3,666, the lowest tender was accepted.

​Alfred Shuttleworth, the son of Joseph Shuttleworth bought the house in August 1888 and made several additions and improvements to Eastgate House: William Watkins designed additions in 1888, possibly the west wing; Otter and Broughton erected an engine house in 1890; Mortimer and Sons designed a billiard room in 1896.



The Dolphin*, one of the oldest inns in Lincoln, stood at the corner of Eastgate and Priorygate. Alfred Shuttleworth purchased it in about 1892 and had it demolished as it spoilt his view of the Cathedral from his home, Eastgate House, now the Lincoln Hotel. Although the demolition of the Dolphins caused much distress among the people of Lincoln at the time, it is obvious that the northeast view of the Cathedral was considerably improved. It also left room for the erection of Tennyson's statue in 1905. 

Alfred Shuttleworth paid for the restoration and half-timbering of the 17th century building on the opposite side of Priorygate. It became known as "Shuttleworth's Rest" and "The Rest". The interior of the ground floor was fitted out with fixed benches so that those who had walked up the hill from lower Lincoln could have a rest.



It now houses the property department of Lincoln Cathedral.

There was a robbery at the house on 17th December 1909, Shuttleworth offered a £100 reward for the conviction of the culprits and recovery of his 27 snuff boxes, valued at over £1,000.

Eastgate House
from Northgate

Alfred Shuttleworth passed away in 1925.  Alfred Shuttleworth's executors offered the house for sale in July 1926 with J D Wood & Co of London and J Peacock Rayner of Lincoln. The description included: "Four spacious reception rooms, billiard room, five principal bedrooms, four secondary bedrooms, seven servants' bedrooms. Electric light, central heating, stabling, garage, outbuildings. Delightful pleasure gardens. Fruit and kitchen gardens, glasshouses, etc. in all about 4 1/2 acres.


Alfred Shuttleworth's pictures and art treasures were sold at Christie's in London. The first day's sale on 3rd February 1926 included old French and English snuff boxes, bonbonnieres, scent, seals, etc. On the Thursday Chippendale, Sheraton and other English furniture, Persian carpets and rugs. On the 5th February modern pictures and watercolours by many well-known English artists of birds landscapes and Cathedral cities.


Eastgate House became home to Thomas Maynard-Page (1854-1941), a Lincoln solicitor. Part of the house was The Eastgate Court Cafe, operated by "the Misses Green", the cafe was still in business in 1959.




Part of the house became an officer's club during World War 2. The Page family lived in the west wing adjoining East Bight.

Alfred Shuttleworth's west wing,
the only surviving part of Eastgate House.

The main part of the house was demolished in the early 1960s and the reinforced concrete Eastgate Hotel was constructed. The wing that Alfred Shuttleworth built was retained and a new section was built to join the two halves together. Trust Houses bought the hotel when it was completed.